New Hotel Photo Classification and Moderation HIT signup

[Cliff DesPeaux]

Hi all,

At some point in the next few days I will be posting a new type of hotel photo classification and moderation HIT I am setting up as an initial test. I am hoping to use this thread to recruit workers for a qual group for these HITs, and to be available to answer any questions and solicit feedback before, during, and after the test.

Guidelines: https://sites.google.com/view/image-review-guidelines/ugc-photo-moderation

Qual group signup form: https://goo.gl/forms/0dPEHYBipDpB0yaw2

Please let me know if you have any questions.

Thanks!
Cliff

 

[Member9]

Will these be for different qualifications than the ones currently used? Like if I have the current quals should I sign up for this set as well?

 

[Cliff DesPeaux]

Will these be for different qualifications than the ones currently used? Like if I have the current quals should I sign up for this set as well?

Different qual group and on a different account I use for testing, so please sign up for this one too.

The reason for this is because these images have different moderation guidelines and I don't want to confuse workers of the existing HITs.

 

[Cliff DesPeaux]

I am about to post some HITs. I'll be here for questions/feedback.

 

[Barbwire]

how many do you recommend we complete?

 

[kryss]

I am about to post some HITs. I'll be here for questions/feedback.

Just curious if this is going to be the same pay structure for the HITS?

 

[Cliff DesPeaux]

Just curious if this is going to be the same pay structure for the HITS?

What do you mean?

 

[Cliff DesPeaux]

how many do you recommend we complete?

As many as you'd like!

 

[kryss]

What do you mean?

Classifying 5 images for .05 per HIT.

 

[Cliff DesPeaux]

They are posted with the title "Image Classification and Moderation" (sorry, not sure the best way to link to the HITs directly).

 

[Cliff DesPeaux]

Classifying 5 images for .05 per HIT.

That's the plan for this test.

 

[YAHU]

What should we do for landmarks, etc.


Also, will the other hotel photo hits still be posted alongside these?

 

[Cliff DesPeaux]

What should we do for landmarks, etc.


Also, will the other hotel photo hits still be posted alongside these?

Non-hotel images are allowed in these HITs; the requirements are slightly different vs. the other HITs. And yes, this is an unrelated project from the other HITs.

 

[Astro]

With all due respect, 5 cents per HIT (.01 per image classification) seems like exceptionally low pay for the amount of consideration and review needed on these tasks. Is this the exact pay structure workers should expect when these are rolled out into fully qualified campaigns?

 

[Member9]

Non-hotel images are allowed in these HITs.

There's no classification/sub-classification to put them under. Those images don't fit in any of the existing categories for what part of the hotel the image is of.

 

[Cliff DesPeaux]

There's no classification/sub-classification to put them under. Those images don't fit in any of the existing categories for what part of the hotel the image is of.

Thank you for the feedback! Good info to have. Are there any categories you can suggest to add?

 

[Cliff DesPeaux]

With all due respect, 5 cents per HIT (.01 per image classification) seems like exceptionally low pay for the amount of consideration and review needed on these tasks. Is this the exact pay structure workers should expect when these are rolled out into fully qualified campaigns?

Thank you for the feedback. What do you think is a more reasonable rate per image?

 

[YAHU]

Thank you for the feedback! Good info to have. Are there any categories you can suggest to add?

Exterior -> landmark/attraction maybe so that you dont have to add another overall category

 

[Member9]

With all due respect, 5 cents per HIT (.01 per image classification) seems like exceptionally low pay for the amount of consideration and review needed on these tasks. Is this the exact pay structure workers should expect when these are rolled out into fully qualified campaigns?

Agreed. This is the existing .08 and .10 HITs combined into one, for way less pay. I don't know very many experienced turkers who would prioritize completing these for the .05 pay when there's plenty of better paying tasks on the platform at any given time.

 

[Cliff DesPeaux]

Agreed. This is the existing .08 and .10 HITs combined into one, for way less pay. I don't know very many experienced turkers who would prioritize completing these for the .05 pay when there's plenty of better paying tasks on the platform at any given time.

Would $0.10/HIT make these more desirable?