So once Henry approves, I feel like we should all buy Michele lunch or something. Thanks Michele!
What the hell. I DID catch that HIT, and using Mturk Suite, hovering over the requester name said that they were a new requester. I clicked on TV anyways, just to see, because sometimes Mturk Suite shows new requester even when they're not. Guess what, there's no reviews on TV. So I assumed they're a new requester and didn't want to risk doing that many HITs for them.
If I had clicked on TO, I would've saw that they do have reviews, dating back to 2014. Lesson learned. From now on, if I see a decent batch from a seemly new requester, I'm going to click on TV, TO 1 AND TO 2 just to confirm that they do or do not have any reviews. I just missed 50 bucks for no reasons. *facepalm* feelsbadman, I'm going to bang my head against a wall now.