Mechanical Turk Suspensions and General Speculation

imGreek

New Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2018
Messages
7
Reaction score
11
Points
3
Age
26
Gender
Male
You guys aren't offending me. Dont worry about it. I'll post up screenshots of what I use, but as I said above it's just TM, TO and a few dashboard improvement scripts. From the sounds of it, they are being overly cautious and swinging down the ban hammer.

This morning I finally got a response, which seems like the regular one everyone else is getting.

"We regret to inform you that your Amazon Mechanical Turk account has been suspended effective immediately. Your account was closed due to violation of section 3b of our Participation Agreement, which states you will not use robots, scripts, or other automated methods as a substitute for your human intelligence or independent judgment to perform Tasks."

Do I wait 2 or 3 days how or message them again and tell them to look into it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Metallica

Metallica

Never free, never me
Mentor
Contributor
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
5,180
Reaction score
13,877
Points
1,113
Age
28
Gender
Male
You guys aren't offending me. Dont worry about it. I'll post up screenshots of what I use, but as I said above it's just TM, TO and a few dashboard improvement scripts. From the sounds of it, they are being overly cautious and swinging down the ban hammer.

This morning I finally got a response, which seems like the regular one everyone else is getting.

"We regret to inform you that your Amazon Mechanical Turk account has been suspended effective immediately. Your account was closed due to violation of section 3b of our Participation Agreement, which states you will not use robots, scripts, or other automated methods as a substitute for your human intelligence or independent judgment to perform Tasks."

Do I wait 2 or 3 days how or message them again and tell them to look into it?
You always want to annoy them as much as you can. I'd personally recommend never giving them a day or two after they reply back to you. Maybe more like an hour or two :wink:

That's the same message the person who had Stax installed got (again, not saying you were using it). Were you running an AutoHotKey scripts or were the scripts you were using maybe modified in some way? They have absolutely no reason to ban just you for using the scripts you mentioned, because they would have to ban almost everyone on the platform. Additionally, any chance you were using something like an auto clicker? As strange as that question sounds, I've had someone say they suspect they were banned over using one... so it never hurts to ask, right? Lastly, were you using any software such as X-Mouse that allow you to map certain functions to specific buttons? I could see that being an issue depending on what the function is.
 
Last edited:

imGreek

New Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2018
Messages
7
Reaction score
11
Points
3
Age
26
Gender
Male
That's the same message the person who had Stax installed got (again, not saying you were using it). Were you running an AutoHotKey scripts or were the scripts you were using maybe modified in some way? They have absolutely no reason to ban just you for using the scripts you mentioned, because they would have to ban almost everyone on the platform. Additionally, any chance you were using something like an auto clicker? As strange as that question sounds, I've had someone say they suspect they were banned over using one... so it never hurts to ask, right? Lastly, were you using any software such as X-Mouse that allow you to map certain functions to specific buttons? I could see that being an issue depending on what the function is.
Nope, none of that. I've actually started use less things since the new interface, because I founded searching manually and refreshing pages has worked better for me. Only things installed at the moment are [MTurk Worker] Dashboard Enhancer, TimerInTitlebar, Turkmaster (Mturk), and turkopticon. I've kept it simple because it works for me and I make as much money as I did before the change.

Now...the good news! Account is back, which is great! But their explanation still puzzles me. I haven't received a hard block in years, let alone "similiar bot like behavior" is quite ambiguous. I usually fill in work between batches, closed qual, and high paying surveys with hits that are surveys in the 0.40 to 0.95 range. I've noticed that I'll get the random few every once in a while, that reject, with the reason of "you did this to quick, shoulda taken 8-10 minutes instead of the 3 minutes you did it in, blah blah blah". Think I'll stop doing them altogether. Apparently having the ability to read quickly and get things done, is "bot like activity", coupled with often hitting the daily limit with batches. At least, my account is back for now!

We’ve received your complaints and understand your concern regarding the closure of your Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk) account. Your suspension appeal has been reviewed, and we’ve reinstated your MTurk account.

However, please note that in investigating this matter, we have flagged your MTurk account for repeatedly submitting spam responses to HITs and repeated Requester blocks for similar bot-like behavior that is in violation of our Participation Agreement.

MTurk is a marketplace for completing tasks by exercising human intelligence. We take this seriously, so if you continue this bot-like activity to complete HITs in the future, we may terminate your account without further warning.

We’re sorry for the delay in resolving this matter. Thank you for using MTurk.
 

MarkC

Keep me logged in.
Contributor
Joined
Dec 11, 2016
Messages
1,451
Reaction score
3,616
Points
588
Age
46
Gender
Male
Nope, none of that. I've actually started use less things since the new interface, because I founded searching manually and refreshing pages has worked better for me. Only things installed at the moment are [MTurk Worker] Dashboard Enhancer, TimerInTitlebar, Turkmaster (Mturk), and turkopticon. I've kept it simple because it works for me and I make as much money as I did before the change.

Now...the good news! Account is back, which is great! But their explanation still puzzles me. I haven't received a hard block in years, let alone "similiar bot like behavior" is quite ambiguous. I usually fill in work between batches, closed qual, and high paying surveys with hits that are surveys in the 0.40 to 0.95 range. I've noticed that I'll get the random few every once in a while, that reject, with the reason of "you did this to quick, shoulda taken 8-10 minutes instead of the 3 minutes you did it in, blah blah blah". Think I'll stop doing them altogether. Apparently having the ability to read quickly and get things done, is "bot like activity", coupled with often hitting the daily limit with batches. At least, my account is back for now!
Another piece of the puzzle maybe? I could see Amazon looking at this if they are trying to weed out botting accounts. Pure speculation of course.
 

Kadauchi

Well-Known Member
Master Pleaser
Crowd Pleaser
Joined
Jan 12, 2016
Messages
6,986
Reaction score
21,670
Points
1,263
Another piece of the puzzle maybe? I could see Amazon looking at this if they are trying to weed out botting accounts. Pure speculation of course.
I will make this post here now since it seems that I may have been at least somewhat close.

My Current THEORY (this is not confirmed information)

Its not the tools make you look like a bot. Researchers are mistakenly calling foreign workers that are submitting trash work bots. Not all foreign workers are bad, but there are those who purchase accounts and I believe these are the ones mainly being targeted.

The "bot" epidemic started because a researcher noticed that people with weird geolocations (middle of a lake) were also the same people who had the same bad answers. Instead of rightfully (imo) assuming that its foreign workers buying accounts, using a VPN and just burning through surveys without actually comprehending it.

You have to take the path of least resistance here. Making a bot to complete these surveys is going to be extremely hard to make in anyways that would actually make it profitable. There is too many edge cases and other things to worry about. It much more likely that its just a group that is giving bad data.
 

Metallica

Never free, never me
Mentor
Contributor
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
5,180
Reaction score
13,877
Points
1,113
Age
28
Gender
Male
Another person got their ban removed, and they even got paid $100 (they're the second person I've had contact with so far to have this happen to them). Their situation was unique as they got suspended last year, but gave up trying to get the ban removed until recently. This tells me that Amazon doesn't bother to keep up on who they're suspending and why.

After using your links and sending two e-mails on back to back days, my account has been reinstated as of an hour ago:

Greetings from Amazon Mechanical Turk,

Thank you for your patience while we reviewed your account. We’ve received your complaints and understand your concern regarding the closure of your Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk) account. Your suspension appeal has been reviewed, and we’ve reinstated your account effective immediately. We apologize for the delay in getting back to you. We’ve applied a $100 credit to your MTurk Worker account to compensate for the time it took us to resolve this issue.

Thank you for your participation in MTurk. If you have any other questions or concerns, please don’t hesitate to contact us atmturk-worker-support@amazon.com.

Best regards,

The Mturk Team
Amazon Mechanical Turk

This comes as a big surprise, considering how many hours I spent on the phone without any resolution. Anyway, I just wanted to give you an update and thank you for helping me. Is there any way I can buy you a coffee?
 

Metallica

Never free, never me
Mentor
Contributor
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
5,180
Reaction score
13,877
Points
1,113
Age
28
Gender
Male
A person with 2 requester accounts messaged me about having one of them suspended. Their reasoning was that he provided inaccurate information about where he lived when signing up. Both accounts were using the same credit cards to fund HITs. Originally we thought that might be the cause of the problem, but as mentioned earlier, Amazon gave a completely different reason. I gave him the typical information, he emailed them, they gave him the generic "you're banned, leave us alone" email, then he tried to login to the account again and it wasn't suspended anymore.

So, tl;dr: Amazon removed the ban and didn't tell him they did. This doesn't have as happy a resolution as my previous post, but I guess it all works out. This is the only other requester I've ran into aside from aveline @aveline that had suspension problems.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jan and scrmcasey

Metallica

Never free, never me
Mentor
Contributor
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
5,180
Reaction score
13,877
Points
1,113
Age
28
Gender
Male
A person with 2 requester accounts messaged me about having one of them suspended. Their reasoning was that he provided inaccurate information about where he lived when signing up. Both accounts were using the same credit cards to fund HITs. Originally we thought that might be the cause of the problem, but as mentioned earlier, Amazon gave a completely different reason. I gave him the typical information, he emailed them, they gave him the generic "you're banned, leave us alone" email, then he tried to login to the account again and it wasn't suspended anymore.

So, tl;dr: Amazon removed the ban and didn't tell him they did. This doesn't have as happy a resolution as my previous post, but I guess it all works out. This is the only other requester I've ran into aside from aveline @aveline that had suspension problems.
The requester finally received an email telling him his account was re-opened.. sad to say that Amazon seems to prefer giving that $100 credit to workers only :p (permission granted to post the email, of course I took out any identifiable information)

I find it interesting that they use the same template for both workers and requesters. I don't know what I was expecting.. maybe just recognition that this person is making them money or something?
Hello x,

My name is Michael and I work with the Mechanical Turk escalations team. Your e-mail to Jeff Bezos has been forwarded to me for review.

Thank you for your patience while we reviewed your account. We’ve received your complaints and understand your concern regarding the closure of your Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk) account. Your suspension appeal has been reviewed, and we’ve reinstated your account effective immediately.

I apologize for any inconvenience this has caused. Thank you for your participation in MTurk.

If you have any other questions or concerns, please don’t hesitate to contact us at mturk-worker-support@amazon.com
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jan

Metallica

Never free, never me
Mentor
Contributor
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
5,180
Reaction score
13,877
Points
1,113
Age
28
Gender
Male
I added the following email to the main post, and since it is a public address, I am assuming mod approval isn't needed.
This email is the one you can find on the "Contact Us" section. It is a generic email, but was updated when the site switched over to the new design. I do not expect it to be any more effective than the old one. The personal emails I give to people who PM seem to work far more often, i.e. getting an actual response. (You get to speak to a human!)
 
Last edited:

Buddy

New Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2016
Messages
14
Reaction score
39
Points
213
Gender
Male
Hi, I'm a bit worried since a new requester rejected me saying that I was a suspected bot, which I've never done. I've worked on Mturk for years without having this message. I've contacted the requester and waiting on a reply with why they said this. Should I take some extra steps or wait until I get some reply from this person?
 

jan

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 12, 2016
Messages
11,117
Reaction score
23,825
Points
1,463
Gender
Female
Hi, I'm a bit worried since a new requester rejected me saying that I was a suspected bot, which I've never done. I've worked on Mturk for years without having this message. I've contacted the requester and waiting on a reply with why they said this. Should I take some extra steps or wait until I get some reply from this person?
If it were me, I would do what you are doing- email and discuss it with the requester. The only way this would cause you a problem is if the requester then reported it to Amazon. Chances are, they won't. But you talking to them (reaching out to discuss) reduces that risk even more.

I'd try that avenue only, for now. I wouldn't call attention to my account with Amazon proper at this point.
YMMV
 
  • Like
Reactions: Buddy

chris ryan

New Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2018
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
Points
3
Age
48
Location
usa
Gender
Male
Hi,

I been here since 2016 and suddenly yesterday my account was suspended and the reason is for identification verification. Here is what the email said:

Greetings from Amazon Mechanical Turk,
We apologize for the inconvenience caused by your account suspension.
Your account was suspended pending verification of the account holder’s identity. Per that email, please send us a copy of your driver’s license or an equivalent government issued Identification Document (ID). You can provide your ID by sending a scanned copy to our secure fax line at 1-206-569-1407. The specialized team who handles these requests will only accept the information by fax, so we recommend using an online fax service if you do not have access to a fax machine. In addition, please be sure to type or clearly print the following information at the top of the document to help us identify you:
1. Your first and last name
2. The email you use to log into your MTurk Worker account
Once we receive and validate this information, we will proceed with reinstating your account. Please note that if we are unable to verify your identity, you will not able to disburse your current earnings balance or otherwise participate in the MTurk marketplace.
Best regards,
Ahkeel P
Amazon Mechanical Turk

My question is how long does this process take and is there any other way I can speed it up because I use a large percentage for my bills. Is there any other information or emails you can share with me to help this along faster?

Thank you
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jan

greg

Hey that tickles
Joined
Nov 6, 2018
Messages
492
Reaction score
1,482
Points
143
Hi,

I been here since 2016 and suddenly yesterday my account was suspended and the reason is for identification verification. Here is what the email said:

Greetings from Amazon Mechanical Turk,
We apologize for the inconvenience caused by your account suspension.
Your account was suspended pending verification of the account holder’s identity. Per that email, please send us a copy of your driver’s license or an equivalent government issued Identification Document (ID). You can provide your ID by sending a scanned copy to our secure fax line at 1-206-569-1407. The specialized team who handles these requests will only accept the information by fax, so we recommend using an online fax service if you do not have access to a fax machine. In addition, please be sure to type or clearly print the following information at the top of the document to help us identify you:
1. Your first and last name
2. The email you use to log into your MTurk Worker account
Once we receive and validate this information, we will proceed with reinstating your account. Please note that if we are unable to verify your identity, you will not able to disburse your current earnings balance or otherwise participate in the MTurk marketplace.
Best regards,
Ahkeel P
Amazon Mechanical Turk

My question is how long does this process take and is there any other way I can speed it up because I use a large percentage for my bills. Is there any other information or emails you can share with me to help this along faster?

Thank you
I just got a similar account suspension last night. I faxed over the information they requested with one of those free fax programs this morning. Kept a copy of the confirmation that the fax was successfully sent. I hope it doesn't take 2 weeks to get this unf*cked. Between this and Prolific, I've been making about $100 per week on MTurk and that has allowed me to quit another crappy part-time job.

The only thing I can think of is that the "suspicious activity" is that I regularly turk from 2 different locations with different IP addresses. I turk in the early morning at home and then sometimes do HITs at work during my lunch break. I can't be the only one who does this. I imagine there are lots of people who turk from different places.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jan

jan

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Jan 12, 2016
Messages
11,117
Reaction score
23,825
Points
1,463
Gender
Female
I just got a similar account suspension last night. I faxed over the information they requested with one of those free fax programs this morning. Kept a copy of the confirmation that the fax was successfully sent. I hope it doesn't take 2 weeks to get this unf*cked. Between this and Prolific, I've been making about $100 per week on MTurk and that has allowed me to quit another crappy part-time job.

The only thing I can think of is that the "suspicious activity" is that I regularly turk from 2 different locations with different IP addresses. I turk in the early morning at home and then sometimes do HITs at work during my lunch break. I can't be the only one who does this. I imagine there are lots of people who turk from different places.
I turk not only from different locations around town, but I moved a few states to the North. They didn't flag me.

Once they have your information (and process it, however they do that), I think you'll be fine.
 

greg

Hey that tickles
Joined
Nov 6, 2018
Messages
492
Reaction score
1,482
Points
143
I'm going on 2 weeks and I haven't been let back in yet. I've emailed the mturk support account and I get responses back the next day or a couple of days later, saying their "team" has to look into it and they'll get back to me when it's done. I don't know what Stax is so safe to say I'm not using it. I only use MTurk Suite and I'm located in the US. Everything I entered about my account was truthful, so I'm not sure what triggered the flag.

In the mean time I get ~2-3 Prolific surveys a day but that's pocket money compared to what I was doing in MTurk. It's starting to snow here in earnest and the sun sets at 3:30 PM. I'd rather be working but this is getting damn boring.

:poop::poop::poop::poop::poop:
 
Last edited:

chris ryan

New Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2018
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
Points
3
Age
48
Location
usa
Gender
Male
I did git back in two days ago and have been doing hits. But it took 3 weeks and a shit loud of emails too git it back on i hope you got the same by now. But if not i do have some emails add you can have that help me out i think lol.
 
Last edited:

greg

Hey that tickles
Joined
Nov 6, 2018
Messages
492
Reaction score
1,482
Points
143
The email came in last night as I slept - I'm back in. Just about two weeks since I got my suspension. No explanation, no apology. Here's the email:

Greetings from Amazon Mechanical Turk,

Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk) has successfully verified your identification documents. As a result, we’ve reinstated the MTurk Worker account associated with this email address effective immediately.

Please note that in accordance with section 1a of the MTurk Participation Agreement, we have closed any other MTurk Worker accounts associated with you.

If you have any questions or concerns regarding this process, please email us using the Contact Us form on our Worker website (https://www.mturk.com/mturk/contactus).

Sincerely,

Amazon Mechanical Turk
 
  • Like
Reactions: scrmcasey

Delilah

New Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2019
Messages
1
Reaction score
1
Points
3
Age
23
Gender
Female
Hey friends - glad I found this forum and this post! So, I've been suspended since December 12th due to Mturk being unable to validate my identity. Since my suspension, I've probably faxed my ID in with all the necessary info at least 5 times a week, and emailed the general support email the same amount of times that often. I did try the Jeff email the other day, to no avail. I got a few canned responses that first week but it's been radio silence ever since, which I can only speculate is because we're just coming off Christmas/New Year's... although I'm also a little worried maybe that because I've been faxing/emailing so excessively, I might be marked as spam?

Any insight or advice to this would be great! Not sure if I should just keep trying, but my suspension seems to have definitely gone on longer than average.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jan

Metallica

Never free, never me
Mentor
Contributor
Joined
Jan 17, 2016
Messages
5,180
Reaction score
13,877
Points
1,113
Age
28
Gender
Male
Hey friends - glad I found this forum and this post! So, I've been suspended since December 12th due to Mturk being unable to validate my identity. Since my suspension, I've probably faxed my ID in with all the necessary info at least 5 times a week, and emailed the general support email the same amount of times that often. I did try the Jeff email the other day, to no avail. I got a few canned responses that first week but it's been radio silence ever since, which I can only speculate is because we're just coming off Christmas/New Year's... although I'm also a little worried maybe that because I've been faxing/emailing so excessively, I might be marked as spam?

Any insight or advice to this would be great! Not sure if I should just keep trying, but my suspension seems to have definitely gone on longer than average.
Hey, I'll be sending you a PM shortly.

As an aside, this type of suspension isn't the one I made this thread for. Not saying I can't be of any help necessarily, just that I'm not too knowledgeable about this process.

Edit: I updated the thread to say this isn't meant to cover suspensions during the Amazon Payments process. It can be found in the FAQ section. Can't believe I didn't think to add that sooner, lol
 
Last edited: